South Korea constitutional court upholds strict anti-prostitution law

Agence France-Presse

This is AI generated summarization, which may have errors. For context, always refer to the full article.

South Korea constitutional court upholds strict anti-prostitution law

AFP

'Prostitution is violent and exploitative in its nature, and therefore cannot be seen as a free transaction,' says the judges

SEOUL, South Korea – South Korea’s Constitutional Court on Thursday, March 31, upheld a strict anti-prostitution law that punishes individual women who trade sex for money.

The legislation, enacted in 2004, carries a maximum sentence of one year in prison and a fine of 3 million won ($2,580) for anyone convicted of selling or purchasing sex.

Thursday’s ruling centered on a case brought in 2012 by a then 41-year-old prostitute. She challenged her arrest and 500,000 won fine, arguing that punishing voluntary prostitution, especially when the sex worker has no other means of income, violated her constitutional rights.

However, the court rejected the idea that buying and selling sex could be non-coercive.

“Prostitution is violent and exploitative in its nature, and therefore cannot be seen as a free transaction,” the judges said in a 6-to-3 ruling.

The decision sparked angry reactions among sex workers and activists present.

“The establishment has no sympathy for sex workers, driving them to death,” Kang Hyun-Joon, an activist who runs a sex workers association, told journalists.

“Aren’t we part of the Korean people?” sex worker Jang Se-Hee asked tearfully. “They have no consideration for us.”

Prior to the 2004 act, prostitution, while nominally illegal, was largely tolerated in South Korea with officials and police turning a blind eye to thriving red-light districts.

But the law, prompted in part by public outrage over a fire two years earlier that killed 14 young prostitutes trapped in their rooms, specifically criminalized the act of prostitution. 

It led to a significant increase in police crackdowns in an apparent effort to eradicate the practice entirely.

Critics say the legislation has had little impact beyond closing red-light districts and driving prostitution underground, where it is harder to monitor for sex-trafficking and abuse. 

The court’s decision had been highly anticipated after last year’s ruling to decriminalize adultery – a reflection of changing societal trends in a country where rapid modernization has frequently clashed with traditionally conservative norms.

During a hearing into the prostitution case, a lawyer representing the Justice Ministry said the 2004 law was about protecting human dignity.

“In order to root out prostitution, criminal punishment is inevitable,” the lawyer said.

“Prostitution has nothing to do with rights to sex or freedom to choose occupations, as it turns human bodies into the objects of commercial deals,” she added. – Rappler.com

Add a comment

Sort by

There are no comments yet. Add your comment to start the conversation.

Summarize this article with AI

How does this make you feel?

Loading
Download the Rappler App!