A look at Donald Trump’s record on auto jobs

Candidate Donald Trump’s campaign pitch in 2016 to revive United States manufacturing was critical to his upset election victory over Hillary Clinton, helping him capture vital battleground states such as Michigan and Ohio, albeit by narrow margins.

Trump railed against free trade agreements and boasted he would be able to strong-arm Detroit’s Big Three to shift jobs from Mexico to the United States.

But did he make good on those promises?

How have auto jobs fared under Trump?

The trend in US auto employment has mirrored the larger dynamic in manufacturing jobs, rising throughout much of Trump’s presidency, but falling off a cliff in the wake of the coronavirus pandemic.

US auto employment rose 4.6% between January 2017 and the end of 2019, when it stood at around one million. 

But since the coronavirus crisis erupted, employment fell to 919,500 in September, according to the latest estimates from the Bureau of Labor Statistics, down about 3.7% from when Trump took office.

The record is mixed at Detroit’s Big Three, which have traditionally been big employers in battleground states such as Michigan and Ohio. 

General Motors (GM) has cut almost 20,000 US jobs since Trump took office, while Fiat Chrysler has added about 3,000 jobs, based on the latest company figures. Ford‘s overall US employment is about flat over the period, a spokeswoman said.

Has production come back from Mexico?

All of the Big Three continue to make cars in Mexico, though there has been some movement.

In January 2017 shortly before Trump took office, Ford dropped a plan to build a new factory in San Luis Potosi to manufacture a new Ford Focus, saying it would shift the $1.6 billion in funds from that venture into a plant in Michigan.

A year later, Fiat Chrysler announced plans to shift production of Ram Heavy Duty trucks from Saltillo, Mexico, to Warren, Michigan.

Trump cheered the FCA announcement, saying: “We are on the right track!”

But in February 2019, FCA reversed course, announcing it would continue producing Ram heavy trucks in Mexico. FCA currently has 11 manufacturing facilities in Mexico, according to a securities filing.

Kristin Dziczek, a vice president at the Center for Automotive Research in Michigan, said there is no evidence production has shifted under Trump. 

In 2020 so far, US auto production is down 22% from the prior year, while Mexican output has fallen 19%, she said.

“It’s yet to be seen how the USMCA is going to play out on investment decisions,” Dziczek said of the new US-Mexico-Canada trade agreement, which took effect July 1.

Have the Big Three added US capacity?

The major American automakers have both added and closed plants since Trump took office. 

The most dramatic moves were at GM, which unveiled plans in November 2018 to cut 15% of its salaried staff and shutter 5 plants in North America, including facilities in Maryland, Michigan, and Ohio.

Following a bruising strike led by the United Auto Workers (UAW) union, GM reversed course on one plant in Detroit, announcing it would invest $2.2 billion in the facility to make electric vehicles, supporting 2,200 jobs.

On Tuesday, October 20, GM announced a plan to invest $2 billion to upgrade a Tennessee factory to make electric cars, with chief executive Mary Barra touting a “vision of an all-electric future” and saying the company is “committed to investing in the US, our employees, and our communities.” 

FCA in February 2019 announced it would invest $4.5 billion in 5 Michigan plants and develop a new plant in Detroit to build new Jeep products, including plug-in hybrid models. 

Ford also announced new investments in December 2019 after reaching an agreement with the UAW that included $1.5 billion in new spending to upgrade two Michigan plants. However, Ford said last month it would cut 1,400 salaried US jobs through voluntary buyouts.

Prior to COVID-19, the auto industry’s overall performance had been solid if unspectacular, Dziczek said.

“It’s done okay – pretty much been status quo on a lot of things,” she said. “Employment levels were basically flat.” – Rappler.com