LOS ANGELES, USA – Los Angeles is gearing up for the Grammys, music’s marquee night, with Lizzo, Billie Eilish and Lil Nas X leading a pack of young, talented contenders hoping to strike gold on Sunday, January 26.
But revelations of infighting at the Recording Academy, which organizes the awards show, and an explosive allegation of rape has cast a dark shadow over the glitzy gala and rattled the institution’s efforts to shed its out-of-touch image.
On Tuesday, January 21, Deborah Dugan – the first woman to head the Academy, a move meant to usher in a new era for a body long accused of favoritism and a lack of diversity – filed an explosive discrimination complaint with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission.
She says she was suspended after raising concerns over sexual harassment, voting irregularities and other misconduct within the Academy, one of music’s most influential organizations.
In the complaint, the former CEO – who was put on leave last week days before her filing, accused of bullying behavior – also alleged that her predecessor, Neil Portnow, had raped a foreign female musician, an allegation he has rejected as “ludicrous and untrue.”
The ongoing tempest is swirling in stark contrast with the Recording Academy’s efforts to reinvent itself, and thereby appease critics who long have lambasted the Grammys as too white, too male – and too generous to music world mainstays.
Diverse nominee field
This year’s diverse slate of nominees – which celebrates a mix of established and budding stars – did appear to be a move in a new direction.
Leading the pack is the effervescent 31-year-old Lizzo – beloved by fans for her sassy, body-positive persona and unflinching messages of feminist empowerment, sexual freedom and black pride.
She nabbed 8 nominations, including in all the top 4 categories.
The 18-year-old goth-leaning pop iconoclast Billie Eilish and the genre-bending overnight sensation Lil Nas X, 20, both have 6 chances at Grammy gold, while the enigmatic 22-year-old R&B prodigy H.E.R. has 5.
The newbie frontrunners will square off against veteran powerhouses including Ariana Grande and Beyonce, as well as alt-leaning acts Lana Del Rey, Bon Iver and Vampire Weekend.
The shift follows years of sharp critique from top-tier artists including Frank Ocean, Drake and Jay-Z, who have all slammed the Grammys as irrelevant, especially citing its failure to recognize black artists.
Diverse wins ‘more possible’
For John Vilanova, a professor at Lehigh University who has extensively researched the intersection of race and gender at the Grammys, this year’s field of nominees is evidence of “an environment that feels more possible” for different kinds of artists to have a chance.
“It’s quite interesting, to see what will happen when you have artists who are really having their first chance at this,” he told AFP.
“Their work is being appraised by the academy for the first time.”
In her first public interview since unveiling her scathing allegations that the Academy is a “boys’ club” where powerful men line their pockets and promote a misogynistic culture with impunity, Dugan told ABC’s Good Morning America on Thursday, January 23: “I actually wanted to make change from within.”
In her complaint, she said that some nominated artists have sat on the voting boards for their prospective categories.
But when asked if the Grammys are “rigged,” Dugan sidestepped.
“I was trying at each step to take a deep breath and say, ‘OK, I can make a difference, I can fix this, I can work with this team.’,” she told the ABC morning news program.
‘Old Town Road’ all-star show
Though one-time Grammy darling Taylor Swift is up for several awards including Song of the Year, many mainstay artists are not “looming significantly” over the ceremony as they have in years past, Vilanova said.
“They aren’t leading the discourse, they’re afterthoughts – and when has Taylor Swift been an afterthought?”
Often remembered as much for its performances as its winners, the Grammys will feature Lizzo, Eilish and Grande, along with a genre-blending rendition of Lil Nas X’s mega-hit “Old Town Road” that will feature K-pop sensation BTS, country star Billy Ray Cyrus and the eclectic DJ Diplo, among others.
Artists including John Legend, Meek Mill and DJ Khaled – all up for Grammys this year – will perform a tribute to the late rapper Nipsey Hussle, who was shot dead last year and is up for 3 posthumous awards.
Though the Recording Academy drama has threatened to cloud the gala, Vilanova said that in terms of expanding possibilities for artists, the Grammys appear to be taking baby steps toward structural change.
“I hesitate to call it a sea change – progress in these areas rarely happens in a straight line,” he said.
“It’s not that one artist should win – what we want to ask is, ‘Do the Grammys actually represent what the music industry sounds like and looks like?'” – Rappler.com