Senators: De Lima ousted for being 'biased,' anti-Duterte
MANILA, Philippines – In what the opposition called an “unprecedented” development, the Senate voted 16-4 to oust neophyte Senator Leila De Lima as chairperson of the committee on justice and human rights, which is looking into the spate of extrajudicial killings under the Duterte administration.
Some of the senators who voted against the senator said they decided to do so as De Lima had evidently become “biased” in handling the probe.
No less than Senate President Aquilino Pimentel III, President Rodrigo Duterte’s party mate in PDP-Laban, said as much on Monday, September 19.
“I voted yes. It’s better that we have a more objective chairman,” said Pimentel, who was once a client of De Lima in the electoral protest he lodged against Senator Juan Miguel Zubiri.
Pimentel said he is concerned that the committee report under De Lima would be slanted.
“Because I'm worried about the committee report – how it will be written, how the presentation will look like. There should be no slant, no bias from the very start. You just base the report on what came out during the hearing,” he said in a mix of English and Filipino.
While saying it was a difficult choice to make, Pimentel claimed the majority decision is “all for the good of the Senate” and the country.
Senate Majority Leader Vicente Sotto III, in a strongly worded statement, advised other senators to remain “objective” in their conduct.
"What happened in the committee on justice today should serve as an example that the Senate should remain objective and perform its mandate in aid of legislation," he said in a statement.
Sotto said senators should remain “impartial” and not allow the Senate to be a venue for “grandstanding and mudslinging.”
“I urge my fellow senators not to use their committees as a venue to besmirch anyone, to remain impartial and do not allow anyone to use our chamber for grandstanding and mudslinging,” Sotto said.
De Lima violated rules
Neophyte Senator Emmanuel Pacquiao said De Lima violated many Senate rules.
It was Pacquiao who made the motion on the floor for the Senate to declare as vacant all posts in the justice committee, after Senator Alan Peter Cayetano delivered a privilege speech against De Lima and her “allies.” (READ: De Lima walks out during Cayetano Senate speech)
“The Senate rules were not being followed anymore. As committee member and chair, we should follow those rules. A lot of violations have been made. We all know that the committe should not be used for your personal agenda. You shouldn't show your biases,” Pacquiao told reporters in Filipino.
Asked what rules De Lima violated, Pacquiao refused to go into details and just reiterated that the lady senator had violated a number of them.
“I won't go into them one by one. There were too many, if you only knew the Senate rules,” he said.
Paquiao admitted he and some allied senators talked about removing De Lima as justice panel head.
“We had to discuss it because the problem created [by that hearing] didn't damage only the justice committee but the Senate's name,” he said.
Senator Juan Miguel Zubiri said the decision to oust De Lima was nothing personal. Majority of senators, he said, only wanted a “fair” committee chair.
“We voted for yes. We're tired of committees in the Senate being used for political means. I would rather see a working Senate, working committee chairperson that is a bit more fair," Zubiri told Rappler.
For Zubiri, the lady senator has been “anti-administration” in her judgements and decision.
“Nothing personal to Senator Leila, but we feel Senator Leila has already been, well, her judgment has already been anti-administration. So it's very, very difficult,” Zubiri said.
Senator Joseph Victor Ejercito said De Lima and her allies’ efforts to “discredit” and “destroy” the President had “dragged” the country down.
Ejercito said Duterte should be given a chance, as it has only been 3 months since he assumed office.
“It’s the whole country that is being dragged down already. In the pursuit of camps to discredit or to destroy the President's credibility, wittingly or unwittingly, it’s the whole country that’s suffering. Let's give the President a chance…. It’s just 3 months,” he said.
Despite accusations and criticism against De Lima, her allies in the Liberal Party stood by her. Senate President Pro-Tempore Franklin Drilon, senators Francis Pangilinan, Paolo Benigno Aquino IV, and Risa Hontiveros opposed her ouster.
Drilon expressed dismay over the decision, which he – a longtime senator and former Senate President – said was unprecedented.
“Well, certainly I’m not happy, but that’s the rule in the Senate. This is the first time this happened. But we abide by the majority here in the Senate,” Drilon told Rappler.
Asked if the decision was politicized, Drilon refused to answer: “I don’t want to attribute motives to my colleagues.”
Senator Aquino, for his part, called the conduct of the vote “unnecessary and unprecedented.”
The ouster of De Lima, he said, had put the Senate’s independence to the test.
“The new leadership of the Committee on Justice must show that it is fair, unbiased and committed to bringing out the truth at all costs,” Aquino said.
Senator Risa Hontiveros said there was “no overwhelming reason to declare the chairmanship of the committee on justice vacant.”
“If there were issues against Senator Leila’s objectivity, the proper venue for this was the committee on ethics,” she said.
De Lima is also facing an ethics complaint for her alleged immoral conduct and her supposed links to the proliferation of illegal drugs in the national penitentiary. The House of Representatives is set to hold a hearing on the same matter on Tuesday, September 20. – Rappler.com
In these changing times, courage and clarity become even more important.
Take discussions to the next level with Rappler PLUS — your platform for deeper insights, closer collaboration, and meaningful action.
Sign up today and access exclusive content, events, and workshops curated especially for those who crave clarity and collaboration in an intelligent, action-oriented community.
As an added bonus, we’re also giving a free 1-year Booky Prime membership for the next 200 subscribers.
You can also support Rappler without a PLUS membership. Help us stay free and independent by making a donation: https://www.rappler.com/crowdfunding. Every contribution counts.