Duterte: Leaders need to do ‘wrong’ to protect people

Pia Ranada
President Duterte, after his warning to suspend the writ of habeas corpus, says, 'Either we do something to protect society or do something sometimes wrong to protect society'

RULE OF LAW. President Rodrigo Duterte talks about Mindanao history, the peace process, and his campaign against illegal drugs and corruption during the Regional Convention of the Integrated Bar of the Philippines Greater Manila Chapter at the Manila Hotel on November 4, 2016. File photo by Toto Lozano/Presidential Photo

MANILA, Philippines – For someone who has described himself as a stickler for the law, President Rodrigo Duterte sounded almost disdainful of the concept of “rule of law,” saying that, sometimes, a leader has to do the “wrong thing” for the good of the country. 

“For us who has been leaders for a time, we are now made to choose, sometimes, what to do. Either we do something to protect society or do something sometimes wrong to protect society,” he said on Monday, November 14, during the 80th anniversary of the National Bureau of Investigation.

Earlier, he described the Philippines as a country rocked by “rebellion, extremism, and the flooding of drugs,” a situation that forces its leaders to make tough choices.

In such a situation, following the law sometimes leads to suffering and not the improvement of lives of the people.

“We in government are admonished to follow the rule of law and that is what makes it hard, because you follow the rule of law, sometimes it could lead to perdition for people,” said Duterte.

He then said the Filipino people face a tough decision that may require “innovation” of the law.

“I would like to follow the rule of law. It is rules which make up the law. But when shabu was coming in, strong and fast, we had to make a choice. We innovate the law, the rule of law or we let our people suffer. That’s the choice,” he said.

Just two days earlier, Duterte had warned he might be “forced” to suspend the writ of habeas corpus if the state of lawless violence, especially due to drugs, continues. Doing so would allow the government to arrest or jail individuals even without a warrant.  

Based on the Constitution, suspension of the writ may only be done “in cases of invasion and rebellion.”

Duterte appeared to reflect out loud on the moral dilemma of following the rule of law without attaining results for the benefit of the people.

“You know, countries like the Philippines, you do what is right, it is wrong. You do what is wrong, it’s still wrong,” Duterte said.

“And that is how I balance the governance. Whether to do wrong or to do right, to commit a wrong or do a wrong thing, to make it right,” he added.

Duterte, who has long insisted that the “rule of law” is his basis for making decisions, including allowing the hero’s burial of former president Ferdinand Marcos, said the rule of law only works when it is followed. 

“The rule of law and the obedience of the law are just principles of the law and they are really good if everybody follows. The problem is, there is no obedience of the law and sometimes the rule of law becomes a stupid proposition,” he said.

During his speech, he again mentioned the Philippines’ drug problem, citing the outdated figure of 3 million drug addicts estimated by former Philippine Drug Enforcement Agency director Dionisio Santiago. 

He also spoke of the “strong rebellion” in Mindanao and the kidnappings by terrorists in Sulu which have been “putting a shame to our country.”

Acts of terrorism and violence in Mindanao and the spread of drugs were his reasons for declaring a state of national emergency due to lawless violence last September. – Rappler.com

Pia Ranada

Pia Ranada is a senior reporter for Rappler covering Philippine politics and environmental issues. For tips and story suggestions, email her at pia.ranada@rappler.com.