Philippine economy

Lawyer Harry Roque to blame for actions of Laude sister, fiancé?

Carmela Fonbuena
Lawyer Harry Roque to blame for actions of Laude sister, fiancé?
Harry Roque says: 'They're deflecting the issue. The issue is the murder of Jennifer and the accountability of the US serviceman.'

MANILA, Philippines – Armed Forces chief General Gregorio Catapang Jr on Monday, October 27, ordered the Judge Advocate General’s Office (JAGO) to investigate how the family of slain Filipino transgender woman Jennifer Laude, her fiancé, and lawyer Harry Roque were able to enter restricted areas in Camp Aguinaldo last week.

“It is now being investigated,” Catapang told reporters on Monday. It is up to the JAGO to determine if the military police committed some lapses and if complaints would be filed against the protesters.

Military spokesperson Lieutenant Colonel Harold Cabunoc said it appears that Roque was the one who prodded Jennifer’s sister Marilou and Jennifer’s fiancé German Marc Sueselbeck to commit “bold actions” and climb the camp’s perimeter fence. 

Ipinag-utos ni General Catapang kanina ang pag-imbesta doon sa pangyayari na kung saan si Attorney Roque ay nag-uudyok. Makikita naman natin ang mga videos doon sa pagpasok nitong mga intruders sa loob ng security fence,” Cabunoc told reporters on Monday. (WATCH: Jennifer Laude’s sister, fiance climb military gate)

(General Catapang ordered this morning an investigation into the incident where Attorney Roque prodded them to take those actions. We could see in the videos how the intruders entered the security fence.)

Makikita natin na siya pa mismo ang nag-udyok doon sa pagpasok sa fence ng 2 intruders,” Cabunoc added.  (We could see that he [Roque] himself prodded the 2 intruders to enter the fence.)

Roque denied Cabunoc’s allegations, saying what happened last week was “spontaneous” on the part of Marilou Laude and Sueselbeck. 

Deflecting issue

“They’re deflecting the issue. I will not allow it. The issue is the murder of Jennifer and the accountability of the US serviceman,” Roque told Rappler in an SMS message.

The Laude family has filed a murder complaint against US Marine Joseph Scott Pemberton for the death of Jennifer Laude in Olongapo City on October 11. The case has resurfaced debates on the continued joint exercises between Philippine and American troops here, and highlighted prejudices against transgender people.

The victim’s family and Sueselbeck barged into Camp Aguinaldo on October 22, hours after Pemberton was moved to a detention facility inside the military headquarters. (READ: Pemberton in PH camp ‘confidence building’ move)

There are 3 gates leading to the 20-foot container van where Pemberton is detained. The family pushed the first gate while Marilou Laude and Sueselbeck climbed the 2nd gate. The German shoved the military police who was trying to prevent him from further advancing. 

The media followed the Laudes in front of the 2nd gate but pulled out after camp commander Brigadier General Arthur Ang asked them to. Ang would later talk to the Laude family, Sueselbeck and Roque.

After the incident, the Armed Forces filed a complaint against Sueselbeck before the Bureau of Immigration (BI) and the German embassy.


On Sunday, October 26, Sueselbeck issued a public apology for his behavior. “I extend my sincere apology for the incident that happened at Camp Aguinaldo on 22 October 2014. I regret that my action appeared as if I was disrespecting Philippine authorities, especially the Armed Forces of the Philippines. That was not my intention,” he said in a statement. “I understand I was perceived by Philippine military officials as having pushed a soldier in a violent manner. It certainly was not an assault. I could not immediately stop my forward movement but video footage from any of the media covering that event can prove that I never aggressively attacked any soldier. I merely wanted to reach Marilou, make sure she was safe, and join her in asking questions.”

Sueselbeck was scheduled to leave for Germany Sunday, but he was barred from leaving following charges filed against him by the BI. (READ: Laude’s German boyfriend barred from leaving PH)

The military action against Sueselbeck drew mixed reactions online, and Cabunoc found himself in a word war on Twitter on Sunday.

Cabunoc defended his social media engagement. “Ang aking private Twitter ay aking sinasagot bilang public affairs officer ng  Armed Forces of the Philippines. Ito ay hindi pakikipag-away. Talakayan ng idea yun,” he said. (I use my Twitter account to engage people on ideas. I don’t use it to fight with them.)

Cabunoc argued that the rule of law should prevail in making Sueselbeck accountable for his actions inside the camp. He highlighted the supposed “deception” taken by the Laude family when they entered the camp through Gate 6 and hid Sueselbeck at the back of a vehicle when they were prevented from entering another gate, Gate 3. He said foreign nationals need clearance before they could enter the camp. 

Kung nananawagan tayong Pilipino na parusahan si Permberto dahil naniniwala ang biktima na talagang may kasalanan siya, manawagan din tayo na parusahan si Sueselbeck dahil meron din siyang kasalanan,” Cabunoc said.

(If Filipinos are calling for the punishment of Pemberton because they believe that he was responsible for what happened to the victim, we should also call for the punishment of Sueselbeck because he also violated our law.)

Both Pemberton and Sueselbeck have been declared “undesirable aliens” by the BI. –

Add a comment

Sort by

There are no comments yet. Add your comment to start the conversation.