Pro-Duterte bloggers argue for use of profane language after accreditation

MANILA, Philippines – Bloggers seeking Palace accreditation should not be prohibited from using offensive language because it's what makes their blogs popular, said a blogger supportive of President Rodrigo Duterte during a social media forum.

"Some of us openly use profanity, some of us can be very, very colorful, something the traditional media cannot do and that is why we have the reach we have," said Trixie Cruz-Angeles on Thursday, February 23, during the Social Media Town Hall organized by the Presidential Communications Operations Office (PCOO).

She was responding to the idea of the government requiring bloggers not to use "offensive, inflammatory, or provocative" language when they are given Palace accreditation.

The PCOO later clarified that they would only require this for posts on government social media accounts. However, there were calls at the forum for a code of conduct to be imposed on bloggers.

Cruz-Angeles named some of the bloggers who use language that could be considered offensive: Thinking Pinoy or Rey Joseph Nieto, Sass Rogando Sasot, and Mocha Uson.

BLOGGER'S CONDUCT. Rey Joseph Nieto or Thinking Pinoy flashes the middle finger at members of the Malacau00f1ang Press Corps.

Screenshot from Facebook Live video

She said the government should not take away the "advantage" these bloggers have of being able to use profane language on their sites or social media accounts.

"To put in requirements that will obliterate their advantage seems to me...smacks already of regulation," she argued.

Cruz-Angeles likened bloggers to the "wild, wild west" whose no-holds-barred manner of writing is what attracts readers to their sites.

"If traditional media is the very proper East Coast, we're the Wild West where [the] reason why we have such a wild reach is precisely because we are a little freer in our speech," she said.

Bloggers, she said, "precisely have their reach because we don't observe the right conduct."

Definition of 'offensive'

Nieto, who runs the Thinking Pinoy blog, also had problems with imposing a code of conduct on bloggers who receive government accreditation.

He asked how the PCOO would determine whether or not the language used by a blogger is offensive.

"Anong basehan para maging offensive, inflammatory, or provocative ang isang lenggwahe? Dahil po para sa aming mga karaniwang tao lang, maraming mga salita sa amin ay hindi offensive, inflammatory, or provocative pero para sa balat sibuyas ay offensive, inflammatory, at provocative. So ang tanong po, sino po ang magde-decide kung ano ang #disente?" he asked in his video message.

(What is the basis for saying language is offensive, inflammatory, or provocative? Because many of us common people don't find many words offensive, inflammatory, or provocative, unlike onion-skinned people. So the question is, who decides what is #decent?)

Legitimacy

Others who spoke up during the forum insisted on the importance of a code of conduct or ethics for bloggers who will be given accreditation.

"If you're accredited, just follow code of ethics and put a right to reply," said social media commenter Pauline Gaerlan.

Al Alegre of the Foundation for Media Alternatives regretted the "lack of condemnation of online threats and online harassment happening now."

"I would expect government's communication agency to actively protect the freedom kapag binabanatan na online ang mga taumbayan anumang kulay (when people of any political color are harassed online)," he said.

Lawyer Jose Disini said the PCOO should recognize that when it accredits bloggers, it is "lending them legitimacy."

"With legitimacy comes responsibility. There has to be a level of responsibility to which they are accountable to," he said.

Disini added that any mechanism to accredit bloggers should enable government to demand a standard on how bloggers relay information to the public.

"The goal of accreditation shouldn't be accreditation just because you have the audience but accreditation as a way to wean you into a type of reporting. I think people want fair, unbiased unvarnished reporting, reporting without opinion," he said.

Pro-Duterte bloggers like Nieto and Sasot have openly cursed at individuals on their social media accounts.

They've also sought to discredit mainstream media, accusing them of bias and corruption. – Rappler.com

Pia Ranada

Pia Ranada covers the Office of the President and Bangsamoro regional issues for Rappler. While helping out with desk duties, she also watches the environment sector and the local government of Quezon City. For tips or story suggestions, you can reach her at pia.ranada@rappler.com.

image