‘Escudero supporters switched to Robredo to prevent a Marcos win’

Jee Y. Geronimo
‘Escudero supporters switched to Robredo to prevent a Marcos win’
Political analyst Richard Heydarian says Leni Robredo became the rallying point for the 'reformist vote' that wants to stop 'the return of Marcos' to office

MANILA, Philippines – After making his concession speech on Tuesday, May 10, Senator Francis “Chiz” Escudero was asked if he saw this coming – ranking 4th instead of 3rd in a tight vice presidential race.

“I’m always a student of surveys,” Escudero told reporters.

Aral ako pagdating sa mga numero at survey, pero utang ko sa lahat ng sumusuporta sa amin at kay Senator Grace na lumaban, ibigay ang lahat, dahil hindi rin naman siguro tama na tumigil ka sa kalagitnaan ng laban.”

(I’m learned when it comes to numbers and surveys, but I owe it to our supporters and to Senator Grace’s supporters to fight, give our all, because I don’t think it’s right to stop halfway in the fight.)

Early in the campaign, Escudero was the vice presidential front runner based on the surveys. But in March 2016 or less than two months before the elections, Senator Ferdinand “Bongbong” Marcos Jr edged Escudero out of the top spot.

All surveys released a week before May 9 showed Escudero ranked only 3rd place next to Marcos and Camarines Sur 3rd District Representative Leni Robredo, who were in a statistical tie.

Nalalaman naman namin mula’t mula pa na kulang kami sa resources at makinarya, pero sinikap pa rin namin bigyan ng opsyon at pagkakataon at oportunidad ang ating mga kababayan na makapili at piliin kung sino talaga ang gusto nila,” Escudero explained.

(We knew from the get-go that we lack the resources and machinery, but we still tried to give our citizens an option and opportunity to choose who they really want.)

Escudero conceded his vice presidential bid early Tuesday. By then, partial, unofficial results already placed him 4th in the race, next to 3rd placer Senator Alan Peter Cayetano.

In his concession speech, Escudero said he hoped that Robredo, his fellow Bicolano, would emerge as the winner of the elections. 

‘Reformist vote’

But for political analyst Richard Heydarian, what happened was more than just the lack of a political machinery. It had to do, he said, with a strong desire to “prevent a Marcos return to the office.” (READ: Hairline gap between Robredo, Marcos)

“I think the inclusion of Chiz Escudero kind of helped her,” Heydarian said on Tuesday, during Rappler’s live coverage of the 2016 elections.

“Some people would argue she’s unlucky because there were 4 Bicolanos fighting, so the Bicol vote was split the way the Ilocano-Northern Luzon vote was not split. But I think what happened was when Chiz was going down, a lot of Chiz supporters I think switched to Leni because they saw her as the more competitive candidate that could prevent a Marcos return to the office.”

Based on the partial, unofficial results from the Comelec-GMA7 Mirror Server, Robredo currently leads in 5 out of 6 Bicol provinces: Albay, Camarines Norte, Camarines Sur, Catanduanes, and Masbate.

Escudero dominated in his home province Sorsogon, but only ranked second to Robredo in Albay, Camarines Norte, and Catanduanes. Marcos was the second choice in Camarines Sur and Masbate.

Heydarian said with the perception that “the return of Marcos is something we have to stop,” Robredo became the rallying point for the “reformist vote.”

“She gravitated most likely even votes from Chiz Escudero. A weaker Chiz Escudero was better for Leni and was just good enough for Leni to have edged out Marcos,” Heydarian explained.

Cayetano, he said, kept it “strong enough” to deny Marcos votes from Mindanao and the peripheries.

Tight vice presidential race

Two days after the elections, it’s still a tight vice presidential race between Robredo and Marcos. In the partial, unofficial tally, Robredo is ahead by more than 200,000 votes as of 3:58 pm, with 95.55% precincts reporting. 

But on Tuesday, the Marcos camp already raised the possibility of dagdag-bawas (point-shaving) in the Comelec unofficial transmission of votes. On the same day, Robredo urged Marcos to stop “unfair” allegations of cheating.

Even days before May 9, Marcos had already accused Robredo’s ruling Liberal Party of plotting to cheat its way to victory or scheming to oust Rodrigo Duterte if the mayor and Robredo won.

Robredo countered that Marcos was apparently using her to woo Duterte’s supporters as she denied the allegation. (READ: LP’s ‘Plan B’? Duterte ouster if Robredo wins – Marcos)

Aside from Escudero, other vice presidential bets Cayetano, Antonio Trillanes IV, and Gregorio “Gringo” Honasan II have already conceded defeat. – Rappler.com

Add a comment

Sort by

There are no comments yet. Add your comment to start the conversation.

Jee Y. Geronimo

Jee is part of Rappler's Central Desk, handling most of the world, science, and environment stories on the site. She enjoys listening to podcasts and K-pop, watching Asian dramas, and running long distances. She hopes to visit Israel someday to retrace the steps of her Savior.