Senate of the Philippines

Senators refuse to sign Pharmally probe report due to inclusion of Duterte

Bonz Magsambol
Senators refuse to sign Pharmally probe report due to inclusion of Duterte

SENATE APPROVES BICAM REPORT ON SEPARATE HEINOUS FACILITY: Senators ratify the bicameral conference committee report on the disagreeing provisions of Senate Bill No. 1055 and House Bill No.10355 or the Separate Facility for Heinous Crimes Inmates Act. Sen. Richard Gordon pushed for the ratification and adoption of the report during the plenary session Tuesday, May 31, 2022. He said under the bill, the separate facility for persons deprived of liberty (PDL) convicted of heinous crimes shall be built in a suitable location to be determined by the Secretary of Justice, away from the general population and other PDLs, preferably within a military establishment or on an island separate from the mainland. “I am passionate about the creation of a separate heinous facility to solve not just congestion in jails but also to ensure the safety of the public and the convicts themselves. This is just a first step. As chairman of the Senate Committee on Justice and Human Rights, I hope we will push for penal reforms in order to make positive shifts in our criminal justice system,” Gordon said. (Bibo Nueva Espana/Senate PRIB)

Senate PRIB

(2nd UPDATE) 'Kung wala dun 'yung pangalan ni President Duterte for plunder, I would sign it,' says Senate Majority Floor Leader Migz Zubiri

MANILA, Philippines – At least four senators said that they did not sign a panel report on the anomalies hounding the multibillion-peso pandemic contracts of President Rodrigo Duterte’s government done with Pharmally Pharmaceutical Corporation because of the inclusion of Duterte in the recommendations for charges.

“I’ll be very honest about it. Kung wala dun ‘yung pangalan ni President Duterte (If the name of President Duterte was not in it) for plunder, I would sign it,” Senate Majority Floor Leader Migz Zubiri told reporters on Wednesday, June 1.

He added, “I don’t believe it is right kasi circumstantial evidence eh. By association siya eh.”

Senator Sherwin Gatchalian shared the same sentiment with Zubiri on his refusal to sign the report.

Meanwhile, in an interview with ANC’s Headstart, Senator Imee Marcos said that the report done by the Senate blue ribbon committee went “above and beyond the evidence.”

“We were a little bit surprised, if I have to say it politely, that it included the President and encompassed breach of trust and other allegations that had not really been discussed or had been shown by the evidence presented so,” Marcos said.

In a text message to Rappler on Monday, June 6, Senator Sonny Angara said he did not sign the report because he “didn’t agree with some parts” of it.

“Some conclusions were also unsupported by evidence,” he added.

Asked which parts he disagreed with, Angara said: “It’s a very long report and this was during the session before we adjourned for election break but definitely the betrayal of public trust which is an impeachable offense thus requires a certain process under the constitution.”

“If the report had limited itself to the filing of cases against the Pharmally officials and those directly involved then I would’ve signed it and I think the majority of senators might have as well,” he added.

In his privilege speech on late Tuesday night, May 31, Senate blue ribbon committee Richard Gordon told other senators that they “cannot shirk from our responsibilities” by refusing to sign the draft report. It was his last-ditch effort to get more blue ribbon committee members to sign the draft report.

“The Senate’s full disclosure of the Pharmally plunder controversy achieves closure for our people. I am doing this as a chairman in a quandary. I respect my fellow members. I do not try to antagonize them or badmouth them. I respect the Filipino people,” he said.

Must Read

Gordon takes jab at senators for refusing to sign draft report on Pharmally probe

Gordon takes jab at senators for refusing to sign draft report on Pharmally probe

The 113-page draft report was first publicized in February, with Gordon’s panel recommending the filing of cases against Duterte himself once his term ends for failing to go after his appointees and businessmen responsible for the irregularities uncovered in the Pharmally deals.

The report also recommended the filing of cases, including graft and plunder, against Duterte’s former economic adviser Pharmally financier Michael Yang, former budget undersecretary Lloyd Christopher Lao, Health Secretary Francisco Duque III, and several other Pharmally executives and government officials. 

Only nine senators signed the report. Gordon missed to get two more senators, depriving him of the opportunity to sponsor it at the plenary last June 1, when the rest of the chamber could have debated on the findings.

The following senators signed the report.

  • Richard Gordon (committee chairman)
  • Leila de Lima
  • Risa Hontiveros 
  • Panfilo Lacson
  • Manny Pacquiao
  • Kiko Pangilinan
  • Koko Pimentel
  • Franklin Drilon (ex-officio member as Senate Minority Leader)
  • Ralph Recto (ex-officio member as Senate President Pro-Tempore)

Rappler has reached out to other senators to ask why they did not sign the report but they have yet to respond as of this posting. We will update this story when they reply. – Rappler.com

Bonz Magsambol

Bonz Magsambol is a multimedia reporter for Rappler, covering health, education, and social welfare. He first joined Rappler as a social media producer in 2016.