Claim: A video showing police beating some passengers inside a train in Hong Kong is being shared online, claiming that is the situation in that country due to the coronavirus.
Since as early as March 8, at least 3 Facebook users have hosted “watch parties” sharing this video from Hong Kong news outlet Stand News. The Facebook users wrote captions in Filipino saying that those in Hong Kong or at least those in the video “did not want to have the coronavirus.”
Facebook’s Claim Check dashboard flagged these posts. Two of the users have already taken down their watch parties, but the third post by user Brb Mharvz is still up as of posting, with the caption “Ncov in hongkong,” referring to the previous acronym for the virus.
A reader also sent to Rappler a screenshot of one of the posts for verification.
The facts: The video in the Facebook watch parties was taken on August 31, 2019, in the midst of massive protests that gripped Hong Kong.
Stand News posted the original video on its Facebook page on September 1, 2019, crediting the group Rice Post for the clip. A translation of Stand News’ post caption written in Chinese read, “Police rushed into the train at Prince Edward Station, sprayed pepper, waved a baton, and arrested many people.”
As of Wednesday, March 11, Hong Kong has at least 120 confirmed coronavirus cases (and one probable case), with 3 deaths reported among them, according to a Hong Kong government website. – Michael Bueza/Rappler.com
Keep us aware of suspicious Facebook pages, groups, accounts, websites, articles, or photos in your network by contacting us at firstname.lastname@example.org. Let us battle disinformation one Fact Check at a time.
More fact checks on COVID-19:
- FALSE: Vatican confirms Pope Francis ‘tested positive’ for coronavirus
- FALSE: ‘Official’ coronavirus face mask released
- FALSE: Cannabis ‘kills coronavirus’
- FALSE: ‘Photo’ of coronavirus-infected corpses in Wuhan
- FALSE: Video of Filipinos ‘eating bats in Wuhan, China’
- FALSE: Novel coronavirus ‘will not spread in PH’ due to high temperature, humidity
- FALSE: Natural ginger ale a ‘cure for coronavirus’
- FALSE: Media didn’t report novel coronavirus has low fatality rate
- FALSE: Novel coronavirus ‘can be cured by garlic’
- FALSE: Coronavirus can be ‘eliminated’ by high temperatures
- FALSE: Novel coronavirus a ‘type of rabies’
- FALSE: ‘Positive’ coronavirus case in Laguna hospital
- FALSE: ‘Patient tested positive’ for 2019-nCoV in Makati Medical Center
- FALSE: Chinese patient in Alabang clinic, hospital tested ‘positive’ for coronavirus
- FACT CHECK: Misinformation on novel coronavirus that spreads online