U.S. Cardinal Law, forced to quit over sex abuse scandal, dies aged 86

Agence France-Presse
(UPDATED) The former Boston cardinal had fallen from grace after he allegedly shielded priests involved in a wide-reaching sex abuse scandal that shook the Roman Catholic Church and eclipsed his long and at one-time venerated career

CARDINAL LAW. US Cardinal Bernard Francis Law prays during the Eucharistic celebration with the new cardinals on November 21, 2010 at St Peter's basilica at The Vatican. File photo by Alberto Pizzoli/AFP

VATICAN CITY (UPDATED) – US Cardinal Bernard Law, a once-influential church figure forced to resign after failing to stop pedophile priests in one of the biggest crises in American Catholicism, has died, the Vatican said Wednesday, December 20. He was 86.

The former Boston cardinal had fallen from grace after he allegedly shielded priests involved in a wide-reaching sex abuse scandal that shook the Roman Catholic Church and eclipsed his long and at one-time venerated career.

Allegations of molestation and cover-ups seemingly surfaced daily after the scandal erupted in Boston, where Law was forced to resign in 2002 for allegedly protecting predator priests despite evidence they had been abusing youngsters.

In 2004, an investigation established that some 4,400 Catholic priests were pedophiles and that the number of victims from 1950-2002 stands at around 11,000.

The scandal was broken by the Boston Globe newspaper’s Spotlight investigative reporting team, whose dogged uncovering of horrific widespread abuse by priests won a Pulitzer prize and was made into an Oscar-winning film, “Spotlight”, in 2016.

Transferred in shame to a low-key position in a Rome basilica, Law had been recently hospitalized after a long illness.

He had become one of the main faces of a scandal that has dogged the church for decades – and continues to do so.


Earlier this month the Australian Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse urged the church to bring in major reforms after the “serious failure” by Australia’s institutions to protect its most vulnerable citizens.

The scandal there, which found many cases of abuse had taken place in Catholic-managed facilities, has embroiled Australia’s most senior Catholic cleric George Pell, currently accused of multiple historical sexual offenses.

In Law’s case, he was accused of moving priest John Geoghan from parish to parish, despite knowing that Geoghan was believed to have abused up to 130 boys.

It later emerged that Law had also known of dozens of accusations against another priest, Paul Shanley, but had allowed him to continue working closely with children too.

The Spotlight reporters discovered the local Catholic hierarchy, led by Law, had systematically covered up sexual abuse by some 90 priests in and around Boston over several decades.

Born in Torreon, Mexico on November 4, 1931 to an Air Force colonel, Law grew up on military bases and went on to attend Harvard University, where he studied medieval history.

He began priesthood studies in 1953 and was ordained in Mississippi in 1961, becoming known nationally for his ecumenical work on social welfare and civil rights.

In 1984 the pope declared him archbishop of Boston – at the time the 3rd-largest diocese in the United States.

He remained faithful to the strict hierarchies of the Catholic church and was a staunch opponent of abortion and birth control, as well as the possibility of someday ordaining women or loosening traditional celibacy rules of the priesthood.

Fresh controversy

The abuse scandal has rocked the church from Ireland – where one priest admitted sexually abusing more than 100 children – to Germany.

Pope Francis has vowed to take a “zero tolerance” approach, but has been accused of being too soft on pedophiles, extending to them a general policy of mercy he is promoting in the church.

He has also been accused of promoting bishops who have been accused of covering up clerical molesters.

An abuse survivor who resigned from his sex-abuse advisory commission in March said elements within the Vatican tasked with protecting children were instead resisting change – to the point even of defying Francis’s orders.

In the latest controversy, Francis has been accused of allowing the commission to lapse, with the American National Catholic Reporter newspaper saying Tuesday, December 19, that it points to the “causal negligence at the heart of the scandal”. – Rappler.com