Anger grows after deadly French building collapse

Agence France-Presse
Anger grows after deadly French building collapse


As many as 8 people are feared to have been killed when the buildings crumbled in a matter of seconds on Monday morning, November 5, in Noailles

MARSEILLE, France – A sixth body was found Wednesday, November 7, in the rubble of two dilapidated buildings that collapsed in the French city of Marseille, where furious residents have accused authorities of ignoring warnings about the state of housing for the poorest.

As many as 8 people are feared to have been killed when the buildings crumbled in a matter of seconds on Monday morning, November 5, in Noailles, a working-class district in the heart of the Mediterranean port city.

Several other buildings in the narrow street have been evacuated amid fears of further collapse as “all the buildings lean against each other” on the sloping street, a firefighter involved in the search for survivors said.

Marseille prosecutor Xavier Tarabeux told a news conference Wednesday that a person living in one of the collapsed buildings phoned firefighters the night before the cave-in to say “that one of the cracks in her flat had widened”.

She later called back to say “there wasn’t any need to come round”, he added.

It was too early to say what caused the collapse, Tarabeux said.

Firefighters had ordered 105 residents to leave the building, and on Wednesday escorted small groups back inside to fetch some of their belongings.

“It brings back my memories of the war, when I was a child,” said Yoanna, a 27-year-old Lebanese woman.

“I’ve never had to leave an apartment so quickly.”

After searching the rubble for a second night, rescuers had retrieved the bodies of 4 men and two women, Tarabeux told Agence France-Presse (AFP) earlier.

“We’re working hard, so there’s still hope,” a rescue worker told AFP at dawn on Wednesday as his team continued to search the wreckage with sniffer dogs.

But Interior Minister Christophe Castaner had already warned on Monday evening that there was “little chance of finding air pockets” in the rubble.

In a separate incident, a building with 3 apartments also collapsed in the center of Charleville-Mezieres in northeast France, with firefighters reporting no victims for the moment, the local L’Union newspaper said.

One woman was rescued and around 50 more evacuated from neighboring buildings, it said.

‘People died for nothing’

The difficult rescue operation – and the fragility of the buildings – became clear when a third adjoining block partially collapsed on Monday evening.

Google Maps images taken in recent months showed large cracks in the facades of the buildings, only one of which was occupied.

Those on either side were in such a poor state that they had been declared off limits and boarded up for a number of years.

City officials said building experts inspected the occupied building on October 18 and shoring up work was then carried out before residents were allowed back in.

Residents say structural problems were widely known, but city officials did little when alerted about them.

“Everybody knew about the problems,” said Patrick Lacoste, a spokesman for a local housing action group. “People died for nothing.”

Anger simmered among the hundred or so residents and activists who gathered for a meeting near the scene, some of them insulting Marseille’s mayor and his housing secretary as “killers”.

A few dozen people held a moment of silence for the victims.

Adama, originally from the Comoro Islands, said: “It’s only blacks and Arabs living here, so nobody cares.”

“I pay rent – 380 euros ($430) a month – and I even pay a municipal housing tax. But you’ve seen the state of the buildings,” the young man said.

Sophie Dorbeaux told AFP she had left the now-demolished block on Sunday night, November 4, to stay with her parents because her door, like several others, was not opening or closing properly.

“The walls had been moving for several weeks and cracks had appeared,” the 25-year-old philosophy student said.

“It could have been me,” she added, visibly shaken.

6,000 properties at risk

Castaner told lawmakers in Paris on Tuesday, November 6, that he had ordered a building-by-building audit before an launching an “ambitious program for ensuring safe conditions” in coordination with Marseille authorities.

“Nearly 6,000 properties have been identified as at risk” in the city, he said, representing some 44,000 lodgings in lower-class neighborhoods.

Marseille city authorities, who have evacuated and rehoused 105 residents from nearby buildings, believe heavy rain may have contributed to the collapse.

But critics say Marseille’s poorest have long lived in unacceptable conditions.

The neighborhood struck by the disaster is home to many buildings in a similarly dilapidated condition, some of them run by slum landlords.

Local residents called for a meeting Wednesday evening to demand better housing conditions.

Marseille authorities began a vast upgrade plan for the city center in 2011.

But a 2015 government report said about 100,000 Marseille residents were living in housing that was dangerous to their health or security.

“It’s unthinkable that such things happen in our time,” said Christian Gouverneur, who owns a flat across the road from the disaster site. –

Add a comment

Sort by

There are no comments yet. Add your comment to start the conversation.