UN-backed Syria talks restart with rebels on back foot
PARIS, France – UN-brokered Syria peace talks restart in Geneva on Thursday, February 21, after a 10-month hiatus that has seen the opposition weakened and political upheaval in the foreign powers shaping the conflict.
Since April 2016, when rival delegations were last in the Swiss city, government forces have recaptured territory including the former rebel bastion of eastern Aleppo.
Main opposition ally Turkey has forged a partnership with government-backer Russia while the United States, long the most powerful voice demanding Syrian President Bashar al-Assad's departure, is under new and uncertain leadership.
Hopes for a breakthrough remain dim with the sides still deadlocked over Assad's fate and violence on the ground persisting.
United Nations envoy Staffan de Mistura has moderated 3 failed previous rounds of talks and said he was not "deluded" about the prospects for a deal this time.
But he told a weekend security conference in Munich, "it is time to try again."
De Mistura has said the agenda remains consistent with the last round, meaning rivals will discuss governance, drafting a new constitution and organising UN-monitored elections, in keeping the framework laid out by the Security Council in 2015.
But unlike 10 months ago, the rebels "have pretty much lost all leverage", said Karim Bitar at the French Institute for International and Strategic Affairs.
Russia, Turkey, Trump
Turkey, Russia and fellow regime-backer Iran have organized separate negotiations in Kazakhstan’s capital Astana, viewed as prelude to the UN talks.
After a ferocious falling out in 2015, Moscow and Ankara have mended ties and begun cooperation over Syria, including a joint campaign against the Islamic State group (ISIS).
In Munich, de Mistura said the fact that Russia and Turkey were now "talking business" on Syria was a "game-changer."
Moscow's military support for Assad has been decisive, notably in the regime's Aleppo victory, but observers said Russia's renewed diplomatic push could help the Geneva meet.
"The Russians have an interest in leaving this situation of endless conflict," a European diplomatic source who requested anonymity told Agence France-Presse, drawing a contrast with Iran's "blind support" for Assad.
While the UN envoy may see bright spots in the new Ankara-Moscow partnership, the situation in Washington is another matter.
"Where is the US in all this? I can't tell you because I don't know," de Mistura said in Munich.
During Barack Obama's administration the US was a vocal opposition supporter and insisted Syria would not see peace with Assad in office.
But President Donald Trump's administration is "re-looking at everything", the US envoy for the anti-ISIS coalition, Brett McGurk, said in Munich, underscoring that defeating the jihadists was the top priority.
De Mistura said his diplomatic effort was "depending" on "a clear US strategy".
That could prove disastrous for civilians caught up in the conflict which has already killed more than 310,000 people, the head of Human Rights Watch Ken Roth said.
"God help the Syrian people if we are waiting for Donald Trump to come up with a strategy", Roth said in Munich.
Assad: stay or go?
During past rounds in Geneva, the government has categorically insisted that Assad's fate was not up for discussion.
But, speaking in Munich, the head of the Syrian opposition National Coalition restated the rebel position that there can be no deal "as long as Assad remains in power".
In a possible sign of the rebels' isolation on the Assad issue, Turkey's Deputy Prime Minister Mehmet Simsek said last month it was no longer "realistic" to insist on a solution to the Syria conflict that excluded Assad.
And for Aron Lund, a fellow at The Century Foundation, negotiations predicated on Assad immediately quitting power "were always destined to fail."
Adding to the opposition's fragile position is that it is expected to send a divided delegation to Geneva, including possibly some individuals who have not ruled out a deal that foresees Assad remaining president.
De Mistura's office has not yet clarified the make-up of the opposition camp and has not set an end date for the round. – Rappler.com