Birth defect risk 1-in-100 for Zika-infected pregnant women – study

Agence France-Presse
Birth defect risk 1-in-100 for Zika-infected pregnant women – study


The statistical analysis of a Zika outbreak in French Polynesia in 2013-14 that spread to 2/3 of the population is the most rigorous attempt yet to quantify the risk of microcephaly

PARIS, France – A woman infected by the Zika virus during the first 3 months of pregnancy faces a one-in-100 chance her child will suffer severe brain damage, according to a study released Wednesday, March 16.

Zika increases the risk of microcephaly – an otherwise rare condition that results in an abnormally small head – by fifty-fold, the researchers calculated.

“The first trimester is the most critical,” lead author Simon Cauchemez, a scientist at the Institut Pasteur in Paris, told Agence France-Presse.

His team’s statistical analysis of a Zika outbreak in French Polynesia in 2013-14 that spread to 2/3 of the population is the most rigorous attempt yet to quantify the risk of microcephaly, which emerges in fetuses.

Brazil has been hardest hit by the mosquito-borne virus, with some 1.5 million people infected and 745 confirmed cases of the brain-deforming syndrome, but the ongoing epidemic and patchy data have thwarted similarly rigorous analyses.

One study from Brazil estimated the chance of birth defects for mothers carrying the virus during pregnancy at more than 20%, but carried a very large margin of error. 

All told, some 40 countries have reported transmission within their borders since last year, according to the World Health Organization, which declared a global health emergency on February 1.

Laboratory-like conditions

The new research does not prove that Zika causes the brain-deforming syndrome.

But recent experiments, including one showing that the virus singles out and attacks cells crucial to brain development, have left little doubt in the minds of many researchers that Zika is to blame.

A flurry of studies has also established strong links to other rare neurological disorders, including one – Guillain-Barre syndrome – in which immune defenses turns against the body’s nervous system, sometimes causing lasting damage or even death.

A number of factors in French Polynesia – its small population, universal medical records, an epidemic with a clear beginning and end – created laboratory-like conditions favorable to research.

Cauchemez and a dozen colleagues used mathematical models to match different hypothetical scenarios against the number and timing of Zika and microcephaly cases.

“This provided us with a small, yet much more complete dataset than data gathered from an ongoing outbreak,” such as in Brazil or Colombia, the second-most affected nation, said co-author Arnaud Fontanet, also of the Institut Pasteur.

Eight cases of the brain disorder were identified, seven of them occurring in a 4-month period near the end of the outbreak, they reported in The Lancet.

Many questions, however, remain.

One is whether the risk is higher for Zika-infected pregnant women who show symptoms.

On its own, Zika is fairly benign, like a bad cold or a mild flu. In many cases, people don’t even know they have it.

“We think that about 80% of people infected show no symptoms at all,” Cauchemez said in an interview.

Another unknown is whether patterns in French Polynesia are transferrable to Latin American, and eventually other parts of the world if Zika continues to expand its footprint.

Defining a risk period

These populations are far more “genetically diverse,” commented Nathalie MacDermott, a clinical research fellow at Imperial College London who was not involved in the study.

“This may well… alter whether these calculations apply to the current outbreak in South America.”

It is likewise possible that the virus has mutated since the 2013 outbreak, becoming more virulent.

Studies still in the pipeline – looking at data from Pernambuco State in Brazil, Rio de Janeiro, and parts of Colombia – show higher rates of brain-damaged fetuses, said Laura Rodrigues, a professor of infectious disease epidemiology at the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine.

Rather than a single, underlying risk, however, these estimates could result from “other factors, such as the presence of clinical symptoms or previous dengue infection,” she said in a comment, also published in The Lancet.

Dengue, along with the chikungunya virus, are carried by the same family of mosquitos that spread Zika.

Overall, independent experts lauded the study.

“This is an important finding because – as well as advancing our confidence that Zika can be the cause of microcephaly – it also helps us, for the first time, to think about defining a risk period during pregnancy,” said Derek Gatherer, a lecturer at Lancaster University in England. 

“This is sure to have major implications for travel to affected areas by pregnant women.”

Preliminary research also shows that Zika can be sexually transmitted by men. – Marlowe Hood, AFP /

Add a comment

Sort by

There are no comments yet. Add your comment to start the conversation.