Mother of child who got Dengvaxia asks Garin, ‘Nakakatulog pa ba kayo?’
MANILA, Philippines – A mother of a child who received the Dengvaxia dengue vaccine is holding former health chief Janette Garin accountable for the possible health risks her daughter may face in the future.
Iris Alpay traveled all the way from Imus, Cavite ,on Monday, December 11, to testify at the Senate probe into the now-suspended dengue immunization program for public school students in the National Capital Region (NCR), Central Luzon, and Calabarzon.
Garin launched the program in April 2016 even if the World Health Organization and the Formulary Executive Council (FEC) – a panel of Filipino experts who assess which drugs should be bought and used by the government – said no to the mass use of Dengvaxia.
“Gusto ko lang po ring tanungin sa kanya kung nakakatulog pa siya nang mahimbing? Kasi kami po hindi na (I just want to ask her if she can still sleep soundly at night? Because we can’t anymore),” said Alpay.
She is one of the mothers of 830,000 students who got at least one dose of the vaccine, which manufacturer Sanofi Pasteur had said could cause a more severe case of dengue when administered on a person who had not been infected prior vaccination.
“Ako po ay sobrang nadisappoint kasi mismong ahensiya 'nyo ang nagpapahamak sa aming mga anak. You endangered the lives of our children. Sobrang disappointment ang nararamdaman ko ngayon. Sobrang galit ang nararamdaman ko ngayon,” said Alpay.
(I am disappointed because your agency put the lives of our children at risk. You endangered the lives of our children. I feel so much disappointment. I feel very angry right now.)
Alpay said her daughter got sick sick recently, prompting her to write a letter to Health Secretary Francisco Duque III. (READ: [EDITORIAL] #AnimatED: Somebody has to answer for the dengue vaccine disaster)
Duque said he called her to ask about the child’s symptoms. He said he would continue monitoring the child as part of the Department of Health's 5-year surveillance of the health of all vaccinated children.
“Mukhang ‘di naman ito maiuugnay sa Dengvaxia batay sa mga sintomas na sinabi niya,” Duque said. “Pero posible pa rin.”
(It looks like we can’t connect the symptoms she mentioned to Dengvaxia. But it’s still possible.)
Alpay asked if parents of children who would later get sick of dengue can be sent to private hospitals, as government hospitals are sometimes far from their homes.
Duque said yes, as the Philippine Health Insurance Corporation is ready to cover P16,000 in medical expenses of a child to be hospitalized due to dengue.
Fast approval, questionable timing
During the Senate hearing, Senate blue ribbon committee chairperson Richard Gordon presented a timeline of the dengue vaccination program’s approval and implementation.
He noted that it was “too fast,” because even FEC members said the program was “premature.” At the time, clinical studies on the safety, efficacy, and cost-effectives of Dengvaxia have not been completed. An economist also said the price of the vaccine at P1,000 per dose was “too much.”
Garin’s predecessor, Paulyn Ubial, said the timing of the vaccination program’s launch – a month before the 2016 presidential polls – was questionable. Gordon also hinted at a possible “conspiracy,” one that may possibly be traced up to then-president Benigno Aquino III and even former budget chief Florencio Abad.
Gordon grilled Philippine Children’s Medical Center executive director Julius Lecciones, who was instructed by Garin to purchase 3 million doses of Dengvaxia amounting to P3 billion.
But Garin maintained the program was safe based on available studies then. She said she wanted to make the vaccine available even to the poor.
She also said the dengue vaccination program was “not a midnight deal” and denied any corruption was behind the procurement of Dengvaxia. Garin left the hearing at 2 pm for an acute appendicitis operation.
Sanofi Asia Pacific head Thomas Triomphe also told senators it would be a “disservice to the Filipino people” if the immunization program would be permanently stopped.
On Wednesday, December 13, the House of Representatives will reopen its own probe into the matter. The Senate will continue its investigation on Thursday, December 14. – Rappler.com
We keep you informed because you matter
We tell you the stories that matter. We ask, we probe, we explain.
But as we strive to do all this and speak truth to power, we face constant threats to our independence.
Help us make a difference through free and fearless journalism. With your help, you enable us to keep providing you with our brand of compelling and investigative work.
Joining Rappler PLUS allows us to build communities of action with you. PLUS members will receive our editorial newsletters and industry reports, get to join exclusive online conversations with our award-winning journalists, and be part of our monthly events.
Make your move now. Join Rappler PLUS.