Cabanatuan judge who summoned Baguio enforcers ‘arrogant, unprofessional’ – Magalong

Frank Cimatu
Cabanatuan judge who summoned Baguio enforcers ‘arrogant, unprofessional’ – Magalong
The mayor of Baguio City sends a letter to Supreme Court Chief Justice Diosdado Peralta about the 'bully' judge Nelson V. Largo

BAGUIO CITY, Philippines – In a letter sent to Supreme Court Chief Justice Diosdado Peralta on Friday, November 15, Baguio Mayor Benjamin Magalong said the action of Cabanatuan Municipal Court Judge Nelson V. Largo to issue subpoenas for the traffic enforcers who issued him a ticket for illegal parking was “unprofessional and arrogant.”

In his letter, Magalong said, “Judge Largo committed two traffic infractions in the City of Baguio on October 25, 2019, namely: (1) illegal parking of his motor vehicle at the PUJ loading area along Kayang Street, Baguio City Market, and (2) Violation of Baguio City’s Number Coding Ordinance.”

The mayor added, “The issuance of the citation ticket and confiscation of the vehicle’s plate angered the judge and, thus, he castigated the police personnel of the Traffic Management Unit inside the police station.”

Back home, Largo issued an order directing Baguio Peace and Order Safety Division (POSD) officer Bernard Batnag and the Chief of the Traffic Enforcer of the market to explain within 72 hours why they should not be cited for indirect contempt of court.

“This unprofessional and arrogant display of judicial power by a judge to bully those implementing the law, if not rectified by the Supreme Court, would certainly have a chilling effect on our traffic enforcers, not to mention its other adverse effects to the public,” Magalong said.

SC’s Office of the Court Administrator also asked Largo to comment on the incident at the Supreme Court instead. Court Administrator Midas Marquez directed Deputy Court Administrator for Luzon, Raul Villanueva, to ask Largo to comment on these news reports.

Largo claimed that, by enforcing the law, the Baguio officers “delayed his administration of justice.” In his subpoena order, he claimed that the time taken to settle fines and recover his license plate, he claimed  was detrimental to the operations of the Cabanatuan Municipal Court III and as such the enforcers were liable for indirect contempt of court.

Magalong said that regardless of whether or not Largo is a judge, a violation of the law demands the appropriate punishment. “He was given the ticket in the right manner. We are just enforcing an ordinance,” Magalong said.

Baguio Police Director Allen Rae Co said the POSD personnel were acting in good faith just implementing local laws regulating traffic and parking in Baguio City.

“Here in Baguio, we enforce the laws strictly and equally and even our judges and prosecutors and government officials follow traffic rules and regulations,” Co said. – 


Add a comment

Sort by

There are no comments yet. Add your comment to start the conversation.