Binay's 'dear friend' got P1.3B contracts in 4 years
MANILA, Philippines (UPDATED) – Security guards and janitors manning public schools in Makati City could be the highest paid blue-collar workers in the country – on paper.
A security and janitorial company identified with an associate and a "dear family friend" of Vice President Jejomar Binay has been allegedly cornering hundreds of millions of pesos in contracts yearly from the Makati City government. It's a virtual monopoly that bolsters allegations bids are rigged and winners are pre-determined.
From 2010 to 2013 alone, Omni Security Investigation and General Services Inc, a company put up in 1999 and operated at a loss during its first year, bagged more than P1.3 billion ($29 million*) in contracts from the Makati City government.
This excludes the previous years when Omni virtually gobbled up security and janitorial services bidded out by the Makati City government when the Binay patriarch and matriarch were mayors.
Who is Gerry Limlingan?
- Binay’s ‘very dear family friend’
- Binay’s representative in Omni
- Survived an ambush attempt in 2010
- Acted as Binay's campaign manager and finance officer
In 2012, the company apparently split into two – Omni Security Investigation for the security services and Corporate Solutions Manpower and General Services Inc for janitorial services.
Both companies however still share the same addresses and the same contact numbers, based on their submissions to the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). And they remained loyal suppliers to the city government.
In only its supposed first year of operation, Corporate Solutions bagged a P109-million ($2.4 million) janitorial services contract from the Makati City government.
Binay’s alleged ‘bag man’
Omni Security’s alleged ties with the Binay family first surfaced when its former president, Jose Orillaza, claimed during a Senate hearing that he was a mere dummy for the former Makati mayor.
Orillaza said Binay’s close associate, Gerardo "Gerry" Limlingan, was Binay’s “representative” in Omni and while he was not among the original incorporators, Binay made him a co-signatory for the checks issued by the company.
Orillaza said he served as Omni president from 1999 to 2010, and was kicked out for his close ties to former Makati Vice Mayor Ernesto Mercado. Mercado, who lost the mayoral race to Binay’s son, Jejomar Erwin “Junjun” Binay Jr, has been spewing one exposé after another involving his former political patrons.
Mercado said he also delivered money to Limlingan, representing Binay’s kickbacks from city government projects. (READ: Former ally: VP Binay got 13% from Makati projects)
Limlingan has been invited by the Senate to appear in the hearing but summonses sent to him could not be served. Senate Blue Ribbon subcommittee chair Aquilino “Koko” Pimentel III said Limlingan could not be located.
Rappler repeatedly called up the Omni Security and Corporate Solutions office, but was told Limlingan was not available for an interview. We first called his office Wednesday last week and continued trying to contact him until Friday, October 10, but were repeatedly told Limlingan was out and that none of the company's officials were available.
In 2010, Limlingan survived an ambush attempt at the height of the election campaign, prompting Binay, who was then seeking the vice-presidency, to ask the Commission on Elections to put Makati under its control.
“Gerry Limlingan is a very dear family friend. The attempt on his life is a despicable act that deserves condemnation. It is obviously politically-motivated,” Binay said in a statement following the failed ambush try.
In the best-selling book, Ambition, Destiny, Victory (Stories from a Presidential Election), authors and now Rappler editors Chay F. Hofileña and Miriam Grace Go wrote that Limlingan acted as Binay's campaign manager and finance officer during the 2010 electoral campaign.
It was through Limlingan that Binay tapped former professors of the Asian Institute of Management, getting tips on how he should market himself as a national candidate. "He is said to have a very practical management style, one that is needed to make a small team running a big campaign flexible," the authors wrote.
Controlled by Limlingan and wife?
A check with the Securities and Exchange Commission showed that Omni Security company was set up on December 2, 1999, with Orillaza as one of the incorporators. As president of the company, Orillaza said he received a monthly salary of P50,000 ($1,100) to P70,000 ($1,500).
But a corporate shakeup and political alienation, dislodged him from the company.
Its corporate papers showed that Omni Security’s current chairman and president is Marguerite E. Lichnock, the wife of Limlingan. Other officials in the company are also said to be identified with the Binays.
Omni Security’s sister company, Corporate Solutions, incorporated in June 2012, has the same set of incorporators, with the exception of Lichnock. Corporate Solutions has her husband Limlingan as chairman and president of the janitorial firm.
Together, the Limlingans monopolize the security and janitorial requirements of the city of Makati.
P1.3 billion in 4 years
From a fledgling company, Omni Security Investigation and General Services has transformed itself into a major supplier of the Makati City government.
Based on available data posted on the Philippine Government Electronic Procurement System (PhilGEPS), it was awarded 36 contracts from 2010 to 2014, with a total contract price of P1.321 billion. This includes the contracts after the company was split into two.
In fact, the PhilGEPS data showed that Omni Security was the number 2 top contractor/awardee of the Makati City government from 2009 to 2014.
The number 1 spot was taken by Hilmarc’s Construction with P3.7 billion ($82.58 million), with H.I.S. Construction Inc as 3rd top contractor with P1.034 billion. Hilmarc’s Construction has been dragged into the alleged overpriced P2.28 billion 11-story Makati parking building. (READ: Binay’s Makati building overshoots approved budget)
|Makati City’s top 5 contractors/awardees|
|Hilmarc’s Construction||P3.7 billion|
|Omni Security Investigation/ Corporate Solutions||P1.321 billion|
|H.I.S. Construction||P1.034 billion|
|AKH Construction and Trading Corp.||P628.906 million|
|E.C. Sarrol Inc.||P586.973 million|
Before it was split up, Omni Security was awarded contracts amounting to P829.495 million from 2010 to 2012.
From 2013 to 2014, it was rewarded P248-million worth of contracts. Sister company Corporate Solutions bagged P243.761-million worth of contracts for janitorial services.
Figure 1 shows the interlocking names and interests of Omni Security and Corporate Solutions Manpower.
Former Makati General Services Department head and city councillor Ernesto Aspillaga, in his testimony before the Senate Blue Ribbon sub-committee hearing, said that contract bids at the Makati City government were all manipulated and that Binay when he was mayor, and his wife Elenita, who was also a one-time mayor, played an active role in rigging the process. (READ: Former official: Rigged bids in Makati under VP Binay, wife)
What about the contracts for the security and janitorial services?
Rappler sought to determine if there were other bidders who competed for the security and janitorial contracts, but bids and awards officials said they would need clearance from higher-ups.
But based on available data, what is clearly established is that Omni Security – and for that matter, Corporate Solutions – has been the sole security and janitorial services provider of the Makati City government for the longest time.
Public Works Secretary Rogelio Singson, whose department bids out billions of pesos in infrastructure and civil works projects yearly, said that while a company, supplier, or contractor may bag several projects that are bidded out by a local government unit, this does not necessarily mean there is a sweetheart arrangement.
However, “if this particular contractor corners all contracts, then it's time to investigate or replace the members of the BAC,” Singson said.
Then there are the supposed winning bids themselves that indicate there was hardly any competitive bidding at all.
Rappler's analysis shows there is almost little or no difference in at least 10 contracts from 2010 to 2014, between the Approved Budget Contract (ABC) and the contract price. The ABC is the fund allocated for the project while the contract price reflects the bid supposedly entered into by the bidder.
|2010||P111.695 million||P111.691 million||P4,000|
|2014||P137.496 million||P137.467 million||P29,000|
|2010||P128.665 million||P128.662 million||P3,000|
In 2010, for instance, the security and janitorial services have an ABC of P111.695 million and P128.665 million, respectively. Omni bagged the two projects with bids amounting to P111.691 million and P128.662 million.
From the Office of the Vice President
This means that Omni secured the security supply with only a difference of P4,000 from the ABC and the janitorial services with a P3,000 difference from the ABC.
Or in aggregate terms, Omni got a P249.191-million project by a mere P7,000 difference in its total bid.
In 2014, the ABC for security services was pegged at P137.496 million, while the janitorial requirement was pegged at P128.454 million.
Omni Security secured the security contract with a bid of P137.467 million for a difference of only P29,000, while Corporate Solutions got the janitorial contract, with a bid of P128.433 million or a difference of only P21,000 from the ABC.
At least in one contract awarded to Omni – a security service for various public schools in Makati – the bid submitted and contract price won by the company exactly matched the ABC and the bid price, down to the last peso. The project for the year 2011 cost P92,620,604.
But as far as the BAC of Makati City is concerned, Omni Security’s bids were always the “lowest calculated bid.”
Based on his experience at the Public Works department, Singson said genuine competitive bidding usually brings down the contract price by about 5-10%.
He added that transparent and competitive bidding in the DPWH have resulted so far to P28 billion in savings for the national government.
Losses to profits
With the Makati City government as its single biggest client, Omni Security managed to turn around its fortunes in its 14-year existence.
SEC records show that in its first year of operation in 2000, its income amounted to P47.8 million but it operated at a negative, incurring losses of P539,847.
By 2012, its revenues reached P309 million, with profits of P8 million.
Its newly-formed sister company, Corporate Solutions, did not declare any revenues for 2012 and incurred losses of P68,887.
But a P125.692-million janitorial contract from the Makati City government was the bonanza it needed to be in the black. – with reports from Rey Santos Jr and Wayne Manuel/Rappler.com
*$1 = P44.79