Disinformation

[ANALYSIS] How blog on ‘owning nothing and being happy’ became focus of disinformation campaign

Adrian Monck
[ANALYSIS] How blog on ‘owning nothing and being happy’ became focus of disinformation campaign
How did an anonymous anti-semitic account turn a years-old headline into a meme for the Far Right?

Own nothing, be happy. You might have heard the phrase. It started life as a screenshot, culled from the internet by an anonymous anti-semitic account on the image board 4chan. “Own nothing, be happy – The Jew World Order 2030”, said the post, which went viral among extremists. 

How did an anonymous anti-semitic account turn a years-old headline into a meme for the Far Right, and a slogan picked up by mainstream conservative politicians? And what’s the truth behind that “own nothing and be happy” headline?

The story begins in 2016, with the publication of an opinion piece on the World Economic Forum’s Agenda website by Danish MP, Ida Auken, “Welcome to 2030: I own nothing, have no privacy, and life has never been better.” It is the reference for a social media video entitled “8 Predictions for the World in 2030.”

It was part of an essay series intended to spark debate about socio-economic developments – this was the time of the booming “app” economy, and the commissioning editor – hardly a radical – had previously worked for Britain’s conservative-leaning Telegraph. The piece gained a respectable readership and lived quietly on the Forum’s website for a number of years. The video notched up 9,900 reactions and 766,000 views on Facebook

Must Read

[ANALYSIS] What would a law on disinformation look like?

[ANALYSIS] What would a law on disinformation look like?

Fast-forward four years to 2020. The world looked very different. A global pandemic was raging and the World Economic Forum launched “The Great Reset,” promoting the idea of “building back better” out of the pandemic so that economies could emerge greener and fairer post-COVID-19. 

The pandemic magnified many societal ills. The mistrust in governments and leaders that had been building before played into the hands of both fringe groups and state-sponsored actors looking to undermine and weaken rivals. Both came together on the anonymous dark web in places like 4chan’s “politically incorrect” image board. 

The board, which is completely unmoderated, was also used by operators of a Russian propaganda campaign, active since 2014. The intent was apparently to spread disinformation in a bid to stir Far Right outrage about COVID-19 and perpetuate domestic extremism. The means was often via bots that would push a Far Right conspiracy theory to communities on boards such as 4chan. 

Recent analysis explains how this context brought extremists together “using rhetoric that trivialized National Socialism and the Holocaust.” This same Far Right, Holocaust-denying cohort latched onto “The Great Reset,” claiming that the Forum was part of a group that “orchestrated the pandemic to take control of the global economy.”

A number of threads appeared in this vein, dedicated to the Great Reset. One such 4chan thread linked the pandemic, the alleged nefarious control that the Forum exercises over the global economy, and the idea that “You’ll own nothing and be happy.”

It went truly viral, capturing the warped imagination of conspiracy and fringe groups. One neo-Nazi and white supremacist website claimed the Great Reset was a “response to the coronavirus faked crisis” and would usher in “global communism” to ensure “no one will be able to own anything.” 

Its popularity also saw more mainstream figures “dog-whistle” the phrase while ignoring its anti-semitic and Far Right origins. Threads proliferated, the catchphrase “own nothing be happy” snowballed, and even more mainstream news sites, including Fox News, Sky News Australia, and GB News embraced it.  

Russell Brand talked about it in a video that received more than 1.8 million views on Facebook.

Pierre Polievre, a Canadian MP who was the former Minister for Democratic Reform, used it to discredit Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s government, giving rise to a national movement.

The campaign has similarly infected the Dutch political landscape, long targeted by Russian disinformation actors.

In the Netherlands alone, during June 2020, there were an average of 1.5 posts per day mentioning the “Great Reset” among Dutch-speaking communities on Facebook. By October, this grew to an average of 6.3 posts per day and by December, this had more than doubled to 13.6 posts per day.

By January 2021, the figures doubled yet again with an average of 28 posts per day. 

Reuters Fact Check concluded in February 2021, “The World Economic Forum does not have a stated goal to have people ‘own nothing and be happy’ by 2030.”

But the trolling continues. 

Trolls on Twitter and Facebook, for instance, have spread doctored content to promote the falsehood that, through the Great Reset, the World Economic Forum is advancing pernicious depopulation efforts. These include racist conspiracies that claim white people are the primary target for depopulation. Bad faith actors have also targeted the Forum’s coverage of the circular economy (economic systems that aim to eliminate waste by reusing raw materials rather than disposing of them), decrying it as a “top-down agenda” coming from “unelected globalists looking to reshape the world in their image.” These are just some examples amongst many. 

As far back as 2013, the World Economic Forum’s annual Global Risks Report flagged disinformation as a concern, warning then that disinformation could spark “digital wildfires” in our hyper-connected world.

Today, that warning has largely been born out. Disinformation is a serious challenge for regulators, a minefield for individuals who seek the facts, and a barrier to governments and organizations wanting to disseminate important information. 

The consequences of unabated disinformation are dangerous. Disinformation concerning COVID-19 and vaccines cost lives during the pandemic. The revelations around the 2021 Capitol Hill riot reveal how false information around elections can threaten the foundations of democracy. 68% of Americans agree, saying “made-up news is detrimental to the country’s democratic system.”

Moreover, the amount of data now generated, predicted to nearly quadruple by 2025, makes it easier and cheaper to use algorithms for malicious or manipulative purposes with unprecedented efficiency, speed, and reach. 

Must Read

[ANALYSIS] Fake news and internet propaganda, and the Philippine elections: 2022

[ANALYSIS] Fake news and internet propaganda, and the Philippine elections: 2022

“It is important to recognize that misinformation/disinformation is a tactic used to support an oftentimes political strategy. There are a variety of ways that bad information circulates for political gain. A classic example is for an actor to intentionally disseminate false, inaccurate, or misleading information that inflicts demonstrable and significant public harm,” said Steven Feldstein, a senior fellow at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. “Another set of tactics involve trolling and harassment, probably the most common form of misinformation directed against the Forum. Trolling and harassment entail deliberately posting offensive content online in order to provoke or disrupt conversations.”

The story of “You’ll own nothing and be happy” is anything but trivial and offers valuable insights into how disinformation is created and why it’s essential not to perpetuate its spread. 

It also highlights how disinformation derails free speech. At the request of Ida Auken, the Forum removed all the media around her piece because of the abuse and threats that she had faced online. Action to prevent lies being accepted as truth can help avoid similar situations and promote genuine free speech, allowing us all to freely exchange ideas and opinions. 

In a world where the trolls win, more forward-thinking conversations like the one Auken tried to initiate will be tarnished. – Rappler.com

Adrian Monck is Managing Director of the World Economic Forum.

Add a comment

Sort by

There are no comments yet. Add your comment to start the conversation.