Sereno impeachment: Supreme Court OKs release of documents to aid VACC complaint

Lian Buan
Sereno impeachment: Supreme Court OKs release of documents to aid VACC complaint
For a second impeachment complaint, lawyer Larry Gadon asks for more documents, including the results of the Chief Justice's psychological examinations

MANILA, Philippines – The Supreme Court (SC) en banc voted to grant the request for documents made by groups seeking to impeach Chief Justice Maria Lourdes Sereno.

SC Spokesman Theodore Te said in a news conference on Tuesday, August 8, Sereno did not take part in the voting.

The High Court will provide authentic copies of 6 of the 7 documents requested for by the Volunteers Against Crime and Corruption (VACC) and Vanguard of the Philippine Constitution. The groups sent their request letter to SC on August 4, or two days after filing an unverified and unendorsed complaint before the House of Representatives.

The SC refused to release the 7th item requested, which is the memorandum sent to justices by Associate Justice Teresita Leonardo de Castro questioning some of Sereno’s actions which were supposedly done without the approval of the court en banc.

The High Court said it cannot release De Castro’s memorandum because “it remains a matter that is being internally deliberated by the Court, and thus cannot be released until the matter is resolved by the en banc.”

De Castro’s memorandum is heavily echoed in the VACC and Vanguard’s unverified complaint.

It questioned the appointment of Philippine Mediation head Brenda Jay Mendoza, travel allowance grants to Sereno’s staff, and delays in filling up vacancies in the Supreme Court.

SC will release to the groups the following documents:

  1. En Banc resolution in AM Number 12-11-9-SC – Sereno’s supposed unilateral resolution reviving the Regional Constitutional Administrative Office (RCAO) in Visayas in 2012
  2. En Banc resolution recalling Sereno’s resolution
  3. Sereno’s memorandum appointing Solomon Lumba as Chief Justice Staff Head II
  4. Senior Associate Justice Antonio Carpio’s letter on the withdrawal of his signature in the appointment of Lumba
  5. De Castro’s memorandum seeking to recall Sereno’s RCAO resolution
  6. En Banc resolution creating the Needs Assessment Committee to determine the need to decentralize the functions of the Supreme Court in support of its power of administrative supervision over lower courts

Second complaint

On Tuesday, former Arroyo counsel Larry Gadon sent his own request letter to the SC for documents in addition to the ones requested by the VACC and Vanguard. Gadon is preparing his own impeachment case against Sereno.

DOCUMENTS. Lawyer Larry Gadon sends his own request letters to the Supreme Court for his impeachment case buildup against Chief Justice Sereno. Photo by Larry Gadon

Gadon wants to have his hands on the result of Sereno’s psychological examinations, which she was required to undergo when she applied for Chief Justice.

A copy of Gadon’s actual impeachment complaint obtained by reporters show the lawyer will accuse Sereno of failing her psych exams, with the report supposedly saying she was “dramatic and emotional.”

In Gadon’s request-letter, Gadon also wants documents on the foreign travels of court spokesman Te. Asked about it by reporters on Tuesday, Te declined to comment. 

Gadon is also requesting copies of Sereno’s Statement of Assets, Liabilities and Net Worth (SALN). The lawyer is accusing Sereno of concealing in her SALNs millions worth of earnings from when she was a private lawyer who won for the government an airport contract dispute.

Gadon also wants copies of all documents pertaining to the purchase of a P5.1-million Toyota Land Cruiser for Sereno. A budget circular allows the Chief Justice to have a luxury vehicle for security purposes. 

According to Gadon’s letter-request, two motorcycles were also bought to escort Sereno.

Gadon is also requesting a copy of a letter supposedly sent by Sereno to De Castro in May or June 2013, where the Chief Justice allegedly “admitted she deliberately changed recommendation made by the latter in the Temporary Restraining Order (TRO) in Coalition of Associations of Senior Citizens in the Philippines vs Comelec.” (READ: Scrutinizing Sereno, one year after)

Gadon has yet to file his impeachment case before the House of Representatives, as he’s still looking for a congressman to endorse it and still collecting documents to back up his case.

Add a comment

Sort by

There are no comments yet. Add your comment to start the conversation.


Lian Buan

Lian Buan covers justice and corruption for Rappler. She is interested in decisions, pleadings, audits, contracts, and other documents that establish a trail. If you have leads, email or tweet @lianbuan.