House of Representatives

Empty chairs at empty tables: Lack of warm bodies in plenary upsets lawmaker

Dwight de Leon

This is AI generated summarization, which may have errors. For context, always refer to the full article.

Empty chairs at empty tables: Lack of warm bodies in plenary upsets lawmaker

LAWMAKER. Gabriela Representative Arlene Brosas debates with a fellow colleague in the plenary in May 2023.

House press and public affairs bureau

House rules that have been in place since the pandemic allow lawmakers to attend plenary sessions virtually. The result is a House floor with only a small fraction of congressmen physically present.

MANILA, Philippines – House assistant minority leader Arlene Brosas reached the podium stand to interpellate the plenary sponsor of a Marcos administration priority measure, but she opened her speech with an impassioned callout to colleagues who were not physically present in the House plenary.

“How can we be like this? We are talking about the national framework on the land use bill and there is no physical quorum right now,” Brosas said on Wednesday, May 17.

Empty chairs at empty tables: Lack of warm bodies in plenary upsets lawmaker

Current House rules – which have been in place since the pandemic – allow lawmakers to attend plenary sessions virtually.

On Wednesday, 310 out of 314 lawmakers were considered present in the session. But as Rappler also observed, there were only around 20 to 30 legislators on the House floor at the time of Brosas’ interpellation.

EMPTY CHAIRS. Nearly all lawmakers are present in Wednesday’s plenary session, albeit virtually, resulting in a House floor that lacks physical quorum. Dwight de Leon/Rappler

Responding to Brosas’ remarks, House Deputy Majority Leader Lorenz Defensor reiterated that the House’s hybrid setup is still being implemented.

“If the members do not wish to avail of the privilege of being physically present, we leave it up to their constituency if their constituents will find that their representation in Congress is wanting. But as long as our rules stand, the progressive hybrid sessions must be allowed,” he said.

Empty chairs at empty tables: Lack of warm bodies in plenary upsets lawmaker

Brosas said she understands the rules, but she also compared her colleagues to students who have fully returned to face-to-face classes after years of pandemic-driven virtual and hybrid learning setups.

Hindi ba nakakahiya (Isn’t it a shame) that most of our members are not here when we are discussing a very important bill?” the Gabriela party-list lawmaker asked. “Even students are now taking part in full face-to-face classes. Why can’t this plenary do the same?”

“If they are attending via Zoom, we will never know what they are doing, if they are listening or not,” she added. “This should not be the case when we discuss another important measure. The public is looking up to us yet we are not physically present and participating.”

Brosas and her two other allies in the Makabayan bloc already filed a resolution in March urging the House to return to full face-to-face plenary sessions “in light of the right of the people to information on matters of public concern, as well as the constitutional principles of transparency of all acts of public officials and proceedings of government agencies and accountability to the people of the House and all members.”

The chamber has yet to adopt that resolution, which is pending before the rules committee. – Rappler.com

SUMMARY: The Marcos administration’s priority bills

SUMMARY: The Marcos administration’s priority bills

Add a comment

Sort by

There are no comments yet. Add your comment to start the conversation.

Summarize this article with AI

How does this make you feel?

Loading
Download the Rappler App!
Avatar photo

author

Dwight de Leon

Dwight de Leon is a multimedia reporter who covers President Ferdinand Marcos Jr., the Malacañang, and the Commission on Elections for Rappler.